Remembering Google Play Music: A mixtape for my favourite streaming music service

YouTube Music and Google Play Music

YouTube Music and Google Play MusicSupply: Android Central

It is right here. It lastly occurred. Simply shy of its ninth birthday, Google Play Music is useless. Could it relaxation in peace, with a part of its spirit residing transferred to its successor and slaughterer, YouTube Music. Many have paid their respects to the service over the previous couple of weeks because the shutdown commenced, however I felt it solely proper to mourn an ideal music service with some music tracks itself.

Listed here are the songs that exemplify and exalt the Google service I cherished above all others, over Gmail and Preserve and even over YouTube itself. And let’s begin with the place the ending started: with a dying declaration.

Time is of the Essence The dying of a thousand declarations

“Both manner, I give him half an hour,
That is my educated guess.
Nicely, 20 minutes tops, let’s name it ten —
The person’s a large number!”

Google Play Music had been declared useless so many occasions by 2018 rolled round that I began to assume the service immortal, even with the re-launch of YouTube Music. Even YouTube executives obtained in on calling GPM useless through the re-launch, which led to bloggers and streaming music nerds far and huge to begin speculating as to the service’s dying timeline.

A few of Black Friday’s greatest offers are already reside proper now so do not miss out!

YouTube Music took two full years to even strategy function parity with Google Play Music — and contemplating the dismal state of casting on YTM, it might by no means attain it — however that did not cease folks from pondering the service would die earlier than the tip of 2018. Then by the center of 2019. Then by 2020.

Google lastly introduced the precise dying timeline in Could, and the service went offline for many markets in October.

“Time is of the essence or he is— (musical flourish, Galavant dies) Sorry, if solely you’d gotten right here sooner.”

However if folks had hopped on Play Music sooner, may the service have survived? In all probability not. Play Music’s historical past is fraught with issues, despite the fact that it started with quite humble ambitions.

Better of Each Worlds Purchases, uploads, and subscription songs in a single library

“You get the very best of each worlds!
Chill it out, take it sluggish,
Then you definitely rock out the present!
You get the very best of each worlds!
Combine all of it collectively,
And you understand that it is the better of each worlds.”

When Google Music first launched in 2011 — it added the “Google Play” branding in March 2012 — it was two providers in a single:

  • A free 20,000-song (upped to 50,000 in 2015) music locker that allowed you to retailer your library safely within the cloud after which stream it on any pc and as much as ten Android cellphone/tablets
  • A digital music retailer the place you would purchase songs and albums after which add them to your cloud library or obtain them by way of Google Play Music Supervisor

Integrating each allowed you to create and curate a library of music that had each the depth of a multi-million-song catalog whereas nonetheless having all the obscure and out-of-print materials you ripped from CDs again within the 90s. It was really the very best of each worlds, and after I escaped iTunes for the liberty of my first Android cellphone, Play Music was the service I dove into headfirst.

By 2018, Google was the final of the music subscription providers to have a dependable music locker possibility — Spotify and Apple Music can combine native MP3s however it’s spotty and trouble-prone — and I am grateful that the function finally made the leap to YouTube Music.

I am Gonna Make You Love Me Google’s useless makes an attempt to market Play Music

“And I am gonna use each trick within the guide,
I am going to strive my greatest to get ya hooked!”

Google put Play Music entrance and middle on telephones for years after its launch: Play Music was the default music app for almost each Android cellphone from 2012 by way of 2018 (after YouTube Music launched), and adverts for the service have been a mainstay on the Google Play Retailer homepage. To start with, it wasn’t arduous to lure in free customers — a 50,000 music locker service that built-in with subscription music was a singular providing — however as time wore on, it was tougher and tougher for Google Play Music to lure in listeners.

Spotify had already cemented a lot of its maintain on the streaming music market by the point Google Play Music All Entry rolled round in Could of 2013. Moreover, whereas there was a small, devoted following of customers who cherished Google Play Music’s free music locker, the service was arduous for normal folks to grasp and even tougher for Google to market.

I subscribed to Google Play Music the month it launched, and that worth doubled in 2015 when YouTube Purple launched, eradicating adverts from YouTube. YouTube Purple additionally got here with this quirky new half-baked app referred to as YouTube Music, which could not do a lot however was an attention-grabbing first have a look at a brand new type of music expertise.

Bless the Damaged Street Play Music was buggy and bizarre, however value it

“However I obtained misplaced a time or two,
Wiped my forehead and saved pushing by way of.
I could not see how each signal pointed straight to you…”

Another excuse Google Play Music typically did not preserve customers it lured over from Spotify and different providers is that whereas Google Play Music had lots of options (particularly in its later years), Play Music had plenty of tough edges and bugs that took eternally to get mounted.

One such “bug” (that I really adored) on Google Play Music was the way it shuffled a queue. Say you have been on the fifth track of a playlist and hit shuffle: Google Play Music would shuffle the remainder of the checklist, however not shuffle within the earlier 4 songs.

One other drawback that took eons to repair got here with one of many Android UI updates: the scroll bar would cover routinely, and overlapped with the three-dot menu button for every track within the queue or playlist. This meant that about half the time I would attempt to open a menu to “Add track to queue” or “Take away track from playlist”, it’d scroll to a different a part of the checklist as an alternative. This drove lesser followers away to cleaner-designed music apps, however I caught it out for the sake of my beloved Disney Parks music assortment!

Oh, and do not get me began on the ten machine restrict.

Locked Out of Heaven New options have been few and much between

“‘Trigger you make me really feel like, I have been locked out of Heaven
For too lengthy, for too lengthy
Yeah you make me really feel like, I have been locked out of Heaven
For too lengthy, for too lengthy”

Talking of lengthy waits, the wait for brand spanking new options was even longer than that of bugfixes. We might spend years ready for Google Play Music to get any important updates, however even once they got here round, they’d nonetheless be a one step ahead, two steps again type of a deal.

And fortunately I’ve been well-trained into this perpetual state of ready for disappointment as a result of YouTube Music is even worse about this! You continue to cannot shuffle or repeat whereas casting, and we have been ready on that SINCE 2015. Gapless playback on YouTube Music nonetheless is not good, however we lastly obtained it 18 months after the YTM relaunch, and hey, we’re slowly, slowly, slowly rolling out Day by day Mixes and extra customized style stations!

That is tremendous.

Nonetheless Into You Play Music nonetheless had some gems underneath its tough floor

“Let ’em marvel how we obtained this far,
‘Trigger I do not really want to marvel in any respect.
Yeah, in spite of everything this time,
I am nonetheless into you.”

Regardless of actually every part stacked towards Google Play Music, although, this was the one music service that obtained my cash (and my coronary heart) for its whole lifespan. Google Play Music might have been quirky, typically annoying, and it was continuously ignored and put-down by nearly everybody, however it was nonetheless the very best rattling music participant I ever used.

I constructed lots of of playlists in Play Music, and did so simpler than Spotify or Apple Music as a result of GPM let me construct a queue whereas listening to it after which save the queue after I was pleased with it. I am nonetheless holding out hope that finally YouTube Music will undertake this skill, however I am going to at all times be grateful to the yr of it I obtained on Google Play Music.

Google Play Music additionally had one other great function that few different music providers had: the flexibility to construct an offline library with out manually downloading each track in sight. Google Play Music had a setting referred to as “Cache music whereas streaming”; as an alternative of merely enjoying the present track after which deleting the non permanent cached track file, GPM would obtain and preserve the cached track recordsdata.

This meant that if I would began listening to a brand new band however hadn’t particularly downloaded them, I may nonetheless preserve listening to them after I went offline. This, too, is a setting that each single music app ought to steal instantly, beginning with YouTube Music as a result of sensible downloads is a crappy function and customers deserve higher!

Giddy on Up Play Music was left to wither underneath a cloud of uncertainty

“Been appearing fairly unusual, did not need to discuss,
Mm, there is a pep in your stroll.
Smiling so much whenever you have a look at your cellphone
There is a change in your tone.”

Google Play Music’s improvement kind of stalled out round 2016-2017, and whereas staff did the same old upkeep and bug-fixing, we did not actually see any new options throughout this time, and it was for a great motive: that was when Google wrote Play Music off and determined to show its consideration to a brand new app as an alternative.

By 2017, Play Music had been round for 5 years and alter, however it hadn’t gained a lot of a foothold within the streaming market, and the music part of the Google Play Retailer wasn’t highly regarded both. Contemplating in case you purchased a track in your cellphone on Google Play, you could not really obtain it as an everyday MP3 to make use of with different apps in your cellphone, it is little marvel that the music retailer was doomed.

With little momentum for GPM, Google determined to do precisely what Google does every time any of its providers aren’t doing in addition to they need to: make and fully separate service in a useless try for a clear slate that simply finally ends up complicated folks. And they also turned to the red-headed stepchild of YouTube Purple and determined that was the easiest way ahead for its music income.

And whereas figuring out all of the prerequisite offers and laying the groundwork for its “new” service, Google Play Music was left to stagnate and fade away underneath a cloud of rumors and the dying declarations we talked about earlier than.

Think about what number of tens of hundreds of thousands of {dollars} Google spent attempting to remarket YouTube Music that it may’ve used overhauling and upgrading Play Music as an alternative. Think about if Google may’ve been trustworthy to itself for as soon as.

Prepared Or Not YouTube Music’s launch

“Prepared or not, right here I come, right here I come!
You are like a breath of recent air in my lungs.
You and me dance from the night time to the daybreak.
Prepared or not, right here I come, boy, it is on!”

YouTube Music lastly “launched” in Could 2018, with lots of pomp and circumstance, and I used to be completely unnerved by how rapidly Your Mixtape completely nailed my musical tastes — critically, first day, lower than 100 songs into Your Mixtape, it yanked out a little-known Swedish pop woman group I cherished as a tween. It additionally was one thing of a dream come true to have the ability to combine in all of the user-uploaded, never-available-for-purchase Disney Parks music and fan remixes into my library of official subscription music.

That mentioned, the service wasn’t actually prepared for primetime and would not be for one more 18 months.

You could not migrate your Google Play Music library over — that did not come till 2020 — so that you needed to rebuild your library from scratch. Casting was damaged, and nonetheless is at present. Downloads would randomly vanish — and as of late downloads can nonetheless be wonky at occasions.

And naturally, YouTube Music lacked the steadiness and polish of Play Music, having shiny new colours for the participant however having manner too many bugs for a re-launch of an app that had been round for 3 years.

What About Us How the transition felt for Play Music die-hards

“Oh, why are we’re ready? So lengthy, I am suffocating.
Oh, why are we’re ready? So lengthy, I am suffocating.”

Whereas YouTube Music was nonetheless attempting to get its shit collectively, Play Music was left stagnant and unsure. There was no timeline for Play Music’s shutdown till early 2020 — as a result of that is how lengthy it took to get the music locker and migration options made and examined — however as a result of Google had confirmed the eventual migration in 2018, customers spent two years with a sword hanging over their music expertise and library.

Simply getting your music out was a ache.

It did not assist that attempting to get your complete uploaded/bought library out of Play Music was almost unimaginable in 2019: your choices have been both to manually obtain each track individually by way of the GPM web site or you would use Google Play Music Supervisor, a Home windows/Mac-only utility from 2011 that wasn’t very steady to start with and simply type of broke utterly half manner by way of 2019.

Some customers gave up on Play Music and migrated to Spotify since they could not migrate to YouTube Music but. Some customers downloaded their libraries and went again to good old style MP3 participant apps on their cellphone — or internet hosting their music on Google Drive and streaming by way of sure music participant apps.

After which there have been the customers that simply held on to Google Play Music and ignored the inevitable finish looming someplace on the horizon, begging to only persist with the service and the options they have been already accustomed to.

“Let me take the lead! You recognize what I would like! Put my thoughts comfortable… and inform me, what about us?”

Mirrors YouTube Music’s maturation

“So now I say goodbye to the outdated me, it is already gone.
And I am unable to wait wait wait wait wait to get you residence
Simply to let you understand…”

Progress for YouTube Music was sluggish, however regular, simply because it was with Google Play Music, however options finally began to indicate up. Gapless playback arrived! Correct style searching and style mixes changed that ineffective Hotlist tab! Some semblance of library sorting was added — although correct library administration continues to be a great methods away.

Then earlier this yr, we lastly obtained (what I feel is) crucial function from Google Play Music: the flexibility to add private music. As soon as once more, I may convey my private edits and purchases again to my subscription playlists!

It took one other couple of months so as to add the library migration function and allow us to re-unify our libraries from two apps to 1, however with every new batch of options and refined enhancements, YouTube Music slowly began to behave and really feel extra like Google Play Music (in a great way). It felt much less like that fixer-upper townhouse you first lease after you permit the nest and extra like a snug however quirky residence you are blissful to return residence to on the finish of a protracted day.

Regardless of all makes an attempt to make YouTube Music totally different/higher/newer, the service shares lots of the identical traits, flaws, and really feel as the unique Google-made music service. It is like Play Music’s darkish reflection.

Sound the Bugle Google Play Music’s last shutdown

“Because the seasons change, keep in mind how I was…
Now, I am unable to go on, I am unable to even begin…
I obtained nothing left, simply an empty coronary heart.”

We knew Play Music would begin its long-prophesied sundown within the fall of 2020 with the service being utterly passed by the brand new yr. Issues went a little bit faster than die-hard customers anticipated because the service began pushing customers very arduous in the direction of the migration device and to YouTube Music in August.

September rolled in, and the service began shutting down in some markets, the web site unwilling to load and displaying a banner redirect to YouTube Music as an alternative. Then October’s chill crept in and a horror awaited for customers in an innocuous server-side replace: the Android app stopped working, too.

The dying blow had lastly come, and long-time customers needed to make their alternative: migrate to YouTube Music, or take their libraries by way of Google Takeout and go some other place. Obituaries and tributes sprung up, and with heavy hearts, we deleted the outdated app off our telephones and moved on to greener pastures.

By no means Neglect You

“And all alongside, I knew I had one thing particular with you.
However generally you simply gotta know that this stuff fall by way of…
I am unable to cover my reference to you!
I am going to always remember you!!”

Regardless of all of the ups and downs, the digs and the dying knells, Play Music will at all times maintain a particular place in my coronary heart. It was a music service that match my library and my tastes fairly effectively, and I am going to miss having one place to maintain all my uploaded and catalog music collectively whereas nonetheless having the ability to immediately purchase and import any music that in some way escaped Google’s catalog choices.

You have been bizarre, you have been great, and I am going to at all times remorse that I did not combat tougher for you. And I’ll by no means, ever neglect you.

— Ara

Supply from

You may also like